Same deer?

[12341234]

First three pics are last year rest are from this year.

[STICKS-N-STEEL]

my vote is the same deer

[ccleroy]

Same deer..........brow tines and crab claw give it away.......

[PharmHunter]

That is him and I would have killed hime twice this past week!! Get out there and post pics of him dead

[SCBUCKSLAYER]

thats a bruiser anyway you look at him

[Duck'n N Buck'n]

same deer.

[SnakeCharmer]

same deer is my vote

[SCcdp]

Your cohort just texted me a pic of this deer....y'all need to smoke his ass! Or do you need me to ride out there to do the deed?!?

[benman]

I vote same deer.

I was wondering if you noted mostly night time activity with a scrape dripper? I put one out on a small farm close to the house and have a camera full of a couple of nice bucks that always show between 11pm and 2am. I've hunted the scrape line 3 times this year, wind is sort of funky in that section of woods, so I have to be careful when I hunt. I haven't seen the first buck during shooting time, but they show up late that night almost without fail and trip the camera.

[12341234]

Only had the scrape dripper up for a few days moved it to the main property we hunt didnt get many pics on it. This deer has showed up on camera three out of the last 10 or so days. I have sat in that spot and seen lots of small bucks may have had this deer running a doe around me the other day it is real thick in there just saw big body and lots of horn. Gonna try and get back in friday got test today and tommorrow.

[kingstreebigbuckslaya]

different deer!

[DMP]

Looks to be the same one by the crab claw. Antlers look heavier and taller but not as wide.

Id kill him any day of the week.

[Carolina Counsel]

I'll differ. Awfully hard to tell, but his crab claw looks more pronounced this year than last. I would expect the opposite with age.

[Carolina Counsel]

That didn't make much sense. He seemed to have more length to that G4 the previous year.

[12341234]

More info to make it more complicated. I killed another deer two years ago that had crab claw on right 5pts and 4 pts on left with brown tines that are almost identical to this one.

[DMP]

More info to make it more complicated. I killed another deer two years ago that had crab claw on right 5pts and 4 pts on left with brown tines that are almost identical to this one.

Sounds like you've got some identical twins then.

From what I see he looks the be the same deer with the brow tines and crab claw but with age he has gotten more mass, taller tines and his beams have developed more but im no expert.

Wait and see what sportin says. He is our local goat biologist/manager and has many years of experience under his belt.

[fish hawk]

I think so, crab claw on both seasons.

[Sportin' Woodies]

Wait and see what sportin says. He is our local goat biologist/manager and has many years of experience under his belt.

Is that the same deer? Using a combination of genetic trait notation and main beam coaxial chart plotting, I would put the probability at around 72%. Is your property isolated at all? What type of genetic importation do you experience, based on proper stratification of "trail cams"?
Did you plant lablab this spring? The mass of his left g2 increased in compliance with what decomate lablab guarentees to genetically inject into the physical antler development.
If it is not the same deer, my best estimation puts him at "first cousin" or "step brother once removed" lineage.

[Simple Man]

Sportin, are you implying that the whitetail deer is prone to divorce?

[Glenn]

Shoot 'em both and then you'll know for sure.

If the racks match, same deer.

Duh.